We transcribe the interview of Federico Pabon with Juan Pablo Cannata, in episode 10 of the Fernet & Communication podcast.
"If a scandal is a process that puts the reputation of the accused at risk—because it is a process of great emotional turmoil, unstable—it is indeed something that should be avoided and for which means should be put in place to prevent it," Juan Pablo Cannata.
Escándalo It's a well-known word in Argentina. Scandals fuel the tabloid press and midday TV programs. But how do they truly impact the reputation of individuals and organizations? Today we interview Juan Pablo Cannata, a research professor at the Universidad Austral, on phenomena involving scandal, reputation, and public discourse. Every scandal is unique. However, are there any general rules about what to do and what not to do when faced with these events?
—It's true that it's often said that each scandal is unique. But we must also acknowledge that there's a recently established field of study called scandalology . This allows us to identify the basic structure common to all cases, regardless of their individual characteristics. If we had to propose a definition, for example, René Girard speaks of a transgression within an unstable social context, generating a situation of "everyone against one"... And this "everyone against one" situation ultimately harms or leads to the elimination of the individual... In this case, the accused is selected based on arbitrary rules or certain criteria, not always objectively as a guilty party.
This idea that there are a series of rules effectively allows us to have some possibilities of managing a scandal because we know what the steps are in which it will develop.
There are four elements to consider when managing a scandal. The first is, if a scandal is a situation of "everyone against one," to transform it into a situation of "many against some" or "many against many." Therefore, the initial response is to gain allies, to get members of your own coalition to speak out publicly in your defense, to make your point, to highlight the accused's situation.
A third strategy could be to use the technique of reframing , or re-formulating, or reframing the event or the words. For example, reframing a misinterpretation, reframing a phrase that is being given much more importance than it originally had… Reframing the comment as a joke… If this reframing is supported by some evidence and can be presented with some forcefulness, and also manages to gain some allies who support it, then it also has the effect of lowering the temperature of the disagreement and, thus, can begin a path to recovery.
The second point is to apologize for a transgression that generates widespread outrage… An apology and a correction regarding that statement, trying to explain the context, addressing the background a bit more, or simply admitting the mistake, can be a point that also transforms the scandal, the widespread outrage, into a less serious stage of dissent or crisis… And, therefore, initiates a path of improvement in management.
Finally, the last strategy is the counterattack, which can take two forms. One is an emphatic declaration of innocence, framing the critics or accusers as being behind a major blunder, an intentional or malicious attack. The other option is simply a counterattack to try to deflect attention and, so to speak, level the playing field in the rhetorical battle—remaining a "many against many" situation. This avoids a scandal, although it may lead to a process of attrition and discrediting, but it doesn't jeopardize the fundamental structure of social relations.
—Is scandalous communication a well-known "all or nothing" gamble?
In recent years, a concept has developed that some have called "neopopulist scandals," which is the strategic use of this unstable process. This is what is recognized in some leaders, such as Trump, and also in other populist-style leaders in other countries and with other ideological perspectives. What they do is proactively generate shock, knowing that they have a group of emotionally activated followers who are reaffirmed by the resulting scandal.
Therefore, from a technical standpoint, it wouldn't strictly be a scandal because, as we said before, a scandal is objectively defined as a situation of "everyone against one," while a neo-populist scandal thrives on social polarization, pitting one intense group against another. There is an opposing intense group that becomes very angry as a result of this channeling process and is the one that demands sanctions, but there is also a group on its own side that is positively activated.
From a socio-political point of view, it is a very negative dynamic because polarizations do not help to generate social consensus and long-term public policies.
—Literature always recommends trying to avoid scandal whenever possible. Trump, who is now a former US president, defies this and continually and openly seeks out scandal. Why? Does it work for him?
—The neo-populist scandal works for Trump because, by generating this public upheaval through the transmission of the opposing group's values, it emotionally activates his own group. And, in that effervescence of emotional activation within his own group, it can cause some who were in favor of the project but didn't publicly express their views to begin speaking out, and others who were on the fringes of the project to feel challenged by this activation… as if infected… There's a mimicry within the group, and it spreads through that mimicry. The effect of neo-populist scandals relies on polarization. So, its appeal is that it strengthens both poles, including his own. If you play a zero-sum game, then having half plus one means winning everything… And that's the approach of populist leaders, and that's why the tool or strategy of the neo-populist scandal can be attractive to that type of leadership, even though it generates some problems in public debate and medium-term public policy.