CECAP Dissemination

How did Trump survive his inflammatory statements?

11.11.2016

Author: Juan Pablo Cannata (Universidad Austral)

Donald Trump as president. An explosion of analysis and reflections. Shouts and cries (Miley Cyrus's tears in a viral video pleading for him to treat people well were particularly memorable). Among the many questions that arise, I intend to address one: How did Trump manage to survive his inflammatory statements?

The historic US presidential campaign that just ended has once again highlighted that while facts are important, it is the media's processing of words and interpretations that allows us to assign them meaning and relevance. It's a major discussion about the moral suitability of the candidates. It seemed that Trump was beyond political correctness, that morality for him was a thing of the past. However, the reality is that it's alive and well: there are certain common-sense principles that become evident in everyday life and are reinforced when a public action is widely condemned, thus emphasizing the line that divides good from evil, what is accepted from what is rejected.

The scandal sparked by the revelation of Donald Trump's misogynistic remarks ("When you're a star, they let you do it. You can do whatever you want") proved once again that it jeopardized his candidacy, mirroring the international version of the Gustavo Cordera case ("Some women need to be raped to have sex"), which occurred in Argentina last August. Meanwhile, Hillary Clinton's morality was called into question over a matter of words: the use of personal emails for matters related to national security. Accusations and counter-accusations, denials, apologies, endorsements, and even insults. Values ​​and words have been the central focus until the very end of the campaign.

In these times of cultural globalization and a proliferation of voices in the public sphere due to new technologies—every person with a cell phone is a media outlet—the social conversation about values ​​is an increasingly important dimension in the management of public affairs. New publics are coming together to defend positions and claim rights, which consolidates established sensitive agendas (such as women's rights) and propels emerging agendas (for example, animal welfare).

Agendas evolve, and the historical context makes certain issues more relevant. Sociology calls a crisis a "scandal" when a fundamental moral value, a norm indicative of the society we are or aspire to be, is publicly transgressed. Therefore, such a transgression triggers an explosion that communicates a substantive message: this transgression transforms the culprit into someone who harms the community; thus, it is necessary to expel them, to transform them into someone else (it was a "bestiality," Ingrid Beck said of Cordera; "scoundrel," "cretin," "idiot," "clown," were Robert De Niro's words for Trump).

The renowned French intellectual René Girard points out that this type of crisis creates a social situation of everyone against one and tends toward unstable violence. This mechanism was fully activated in Cordera's case—which serves as a point of contrast—where the brutality of his statement rendered his apologies, attempts at qualification, and public defenses completely unbelievable. Sanctions poured in, and all sectors of society expressed their condemnation. Cordera faced lawsuits, cancellations of shows and promotion of his music, sanctions and criticism of all kinds, and even threats. Those who tried to defend him perished with him.

Trump's case has been different. Although he had been sidestepping low-level misogynistic remarks with excuses like locker room machismo or hangouts with buddies, he finally crossed a line unacceptable to the leading figures of his own party, and day by day the list of those who withdrew their support grew. Even George W. Bush publicly announced his intention to cast a blank ballot. However, Trump managed to pull through: he was hit, he stumbled, but he remained standing.

What was the key to withstanding the stampede of Republicans, the harsh criticism, the universal condemnation, and the calls for him to withdraw his candidacy? The central point is that he managed to stem the tide of the media onslaught and transform it into a many-against-many situation. While he didn't eliminate the reputational damage, the accused weathered the tsunami of the scandal. To do this, he employed three strategies: apologizing with a rhetoric of conversion ("I'm not that person anymore, I've changed"), garnering support from others (his wife, his followers, his political colleagues), and counterattacking (he accused Hillary Clinton of covering up her husband's sexual abuse). This allowed him to stem the tide and the collapse. In the subsequent wave of accusations, faced with several women who came forward to denounce abuse perpetrated by Trump, he applied the same strategy: outright denial, discrediting the accuser, and counterattacking. The campaign became more balanced when the FBI again accused Clinton of violating national security by using her personal email for official business.

It is significant that the triggers for these powerful processes were statements, words: in Cordera's case, uttered during a student exercise and first published on Facebook by one of the aspiring journalists; in Trump's case, the leak of a private, informal conversation; in Clinton's case, emails. Values, discourse, and technologies.

The key issue is determining whether what one says defines who one is. If words define us, then immoral, inappropriate, and reprehensible words make us immoral, inappropriate, and reprehensible people. Statements are fundamental as a mechanism for public positioning. Trump managed to convince some that those vulgar and aggressive words were not significant in defining him as a leader, and with that, he avoided a public shaming, although the damage was inevitable. In contrast, Gustavo Cordera was left isolated and was, therefore, unanimously condemned. Hillary Clinton never managed to escape that shadow of corruption that prevented her from taking the final step.

The vast social conversation thrives on thousands of interventions, and the media acts as a facilitator of relevance. Politicians and public figures have a louder voice than ordinary citizens—though the latter are now empowered by social media—and their standing, personal attributes, and social identity are at stake in every intervention. The public sphere is an arena where interests and values ​​are fought for. As in ancient Greece, in 21st-century public life, discourse is as important as action.

* @JuanCannata He is a professor of Public Discourse Management at the Graduate School of Communication of the Universidad Austral.

**Note published on Infobae.com on November 11, 2016. The original article can be viewed here. hereImage credit: https://unsplash.com/

It may interest you

20.11.2026

International media coverage of the visit...
“The Argentine people were able to express their Christian identity...”

18.11.2026

KCI 2026: Communication Management...
EPC Austral and AmCham Argentina presented a new...

Share