The Thread Edition 47 Hilo

Why not retain talent: three big myths about the 'Great Resignation'

15.05.2023

Author: Carlos Wirth

Who saw the 'Great Resignation' coming first ? Beyoncé or Anthony Klotz? The glamorous music diva or the then shy and almost unknown professor of organizational psychology at Texas A&M University? The author of the song 'Break My Soul', “Now I just fell in love / And I just quit my job” , or the one who coined a term destined to go viral in an interview with Bloomberg Businessweek in May 2021?

Both of them . Both were intelligent and insightful diagnosticians of one of the phenomena that most worry organizations today, one poetically, the other as an 'insight': the endless resignations of their collaborators, endless and unpredictable but, above all, at least in appearance, impossible to stop.

Despite all sorts of new policies being implemented, many of them related to promoting a culture of well-being , there seems to be no way to retain talent. But what if, for a moment, we could consider that the best way to retain talent is precisely not to want to? What if we're analyzing what's happening based on concepts or categories that can't explain it? Here are the three major myths that prevent us from understanding what 'Great Resignation' means, and how to manage it better.

A simple way to understand a phenomenon, perhaps too simple, it is true, involves trying to answer three equally simple questions about it: what, why and for what purpose , that is, what is happening (its meaning) , why it is happening (its sense) and what it is doing (its purpose).

In one way or another, whether the questions are explicit or not, almost all attempts to explain the 'Great Resignation,' and almost all actions aimed at remedying it, address these themes: their meaning, their significance, and their purpose. The near-absolute unanimity of the answers has already become a global narrative—a unanimity and, in many cases, a lazy uniformity that sometimes obscures understanding more than it illuminates it, sometimes failing to clarify or reveal anything at all. This is not always the case with myths, but perhaps that is what is happening here.

1. What is the 'Great Resignation,' and what does it mean ? The 'Great Resignation' is, first and foremost, as its name undoubtedly indicates, an act of "Great Resignation." MYTH #1 . The 'Great Resignation' is not, first and foremost, an act of pandemic-related "Great Resignation," but rather an act of self-affirmation , the great protagonist of the 21st century, a celebratory proclamation of one's sovereignty . Those participating are not renouncing an "object," their work, but rather affirming a "subject," their self , wherever they may be.

The most advanced organizational cultures support work environments conducive to self-actualization , one of the great aspirations of contemporary workers, but one that has become insufficient for them : in addition to self-actualization in their professional lives, they now also aspire to self-transcendence , to achieve something that has meaning for others, their colleagues, and also the recipients of the products and services they provide. When they perceive that this is not the case, they "just quit" their jobs, as Beyoncé sings.

2. Why does the 'Great Resignation' occur, what is its meaning? Employees seek more friendly working conditions, flexible schedules, remote work options, policies that promote psychological and emotional well-being and facilitate work-life balance. MYTH #2 . Certainly, employees seek all of the above, and perhaps even much more, but that is not the only possible meaning of their "Great Resignation."

All of the above, or more precisely its absence, poses significant problems for task performance , but those who decide to quit do not do so for that reason, or not only for that reason, but for the inability to see problems as challenges , and challenges that do not primarily refer to tasks but to oneself : a challenge always makes sense, a problem very rarely does.

Sooner or later solutions are found to problems, challenges are for life - life itself is a gigantic, continuous and fascinating 'start-up' - that is why those who are considering leaving their current jobs are not looking to do so to obtain immediate gratifications , as they are usually and unfairly judged, they only reject ephemeral gratifications , such as money, for example, or power over others.

3. What is the purpose of the 'Great Resignation' ? The obvious purpose is to improve one's professional situation. MYTH #3 . Those considering resigning from their jobs do so precisely because they are not thinking solely in terms of work and career.

What they seek, above all, is a new order for their desires, needs, and expectations —a new order that gratifies them all. Is well-being enough? Not if it isn't also relational well-being . These new workers leave their jobs not in search of higher incomes, but primarily seeking higher-quality connections . When the quality of interpersonal relationships is poor, they seek it in new spaces. In this case, the answer to the question " what for?" is not enough; their concern is " for whom ?"

To retain talent in times of 'Big Resignation', we must begin by demystifying the conventional answers to the questions what, why and for what purpose.

And this is the paradoxical key : to retain talent, one must not seek to retain it but to contain it ; the concepts matter. To contain is to have—with others—it is a community of learning, enthusiasm, projects, and experiences, while to retain , according to the 23 Academies of the Spanish Language, is “to preserve something that should be returned .”

In times of primacy and affirmation of subjectivity like few others in history, only those organizations capable of handling the complexity this entails manage to "retain" talent. These are organizations that "contain" and promote this very subjectivity instead of discouraging it, that stimulate expressiveness and creativity, foster free work environments, cultivate "flow" cultures, encourage resilience rather than resistance to the environment, offer career plans, work by objectives, personalized rather than generic compensation, provide more free time, integrate families and friends, and offer interesting training perceived as vitally useful, not just for increasing efficiency. These are organizations that encourage the possibility of finding one's true self in what one does , and vice versa, and that facilitate diverse and varied paths to happiness, or at least a part of it.

Between June and October 1940, the Battle of Britain took place , the first major battle fought entirely in the air, in this case over British skies and the English Channel. Hitler considered an amphibious invasion of the United Kingdom impossible without first destroying its air force.

Near London were several airfields where Spitfire and Hawker Hurricane aircraft refueled and repaired after combat. The story goes, in lowercase, that on the first day of the battle, as soon as the battered planes arrived, the major in charge of the workshops ordered that the undamaged parts be reinforced instead of repairing the damaged ones. When the perplexed mechanics asked him why he had made this decision, the major replied: “Those that were damaged in the parts that these planes have that are sound are precisely the ones that didn't make it back.”

Countless organizations are focused on carrying out exhaustive (visible) “damage control” regarding the 'Great Resignation,' retaining or attempting to retain it. This, in a way, alludes to creating a seductive but almost coercive impediment to the exercise of free subjectivity. However, they lose sight of the fact that there is no greater (invisible) damage for a professional than thinking that their only hope in their job, their sole purpose, and the main and supposedly attractive reason for wanting to retain them is to “be better off,” without actually being better. Beyoncé or Anthony Klotz? Perhaps the humble Royal Air Force major whose unknown name holds a legend.

It may interest you

11.11.2026

La Virginia Marketing Challenge
Nearly 90 students from the Faculty of Communication...

10.11.2026

AI in Internal Communication: from the fas...
The second edition of the AI ​​Survey in International Communication...

Share